17th Century Poetry Essay Format


The earlier seventeenth century, construed as the period extending roughly from the beginning of James I's reign to the restoration of Charles II, witnessed an unparalleled poetic achievement in England. This achievement flourished in part because of the specific transitions England underwent in the period. The institutions upon which the society rested were challenged, which led to unprecedented opportunity for experiment in politics as in poetry. But most of the poetic institutions were in place even before this period began emerging from the tremendous dramatic and non dramatic achievements of the 1590s and they continued beyond the restoration producing the consummate example of Renaissance epic in English, Milton's Paradise Lost (1667), well after the "Renaissance" had ended.

To say, however, that these conditions persisted beyond their logical terminus is, in a way, to impose an arbitrary historical scheme retroactively, to engage in the convenient fictions of "periodizing." Since such deductive reasoning remains an inevitability in approaching a primary text (even with the best of intentions, in the quest to be "historical"), I hope to cull the presuppositions I bring together to inform a larger narrative of literary history as inductively as possible. Consequently, I propose to engage the specific intersections of four thematic categories with three theoretical concerns. While overlapping between topics will inexorably obscure the integrity of each topic, this process should enable a greater comprehension of both the discrete category and the larger concern.

Before I enumerate the categories into which, I believe, all the poets on my list can be organized, I'll explain the theoretical concerns that will order my approaches to these categories. The first theoretical concern, broadly conceived, is represented by the dyad structure and epistemology. By beginning with structure, I intend to demonstrate how an intimate knowledge of the intrinsic forms of a work of art contribute to (and indeed govern) the work's modes of meaning. To say this is not to reduce or oversimplify the concerns that a poet's sense of intrinsic form engages: the form of the content always relates to the epistemological concerns of the writer. In choosing the word "epistemology," I indicate the period's interest in its own new and inherited forms of knowledge, specifically religious, scientific, and classical.

The second theoretical concern meets the first on many levels. Politics and genre the two terms that best represent this next concern are historically entwined in every period, but especially so in a period in which the education of the young depends so heavily upon the study of rhetoric. That is to say, in literature, genre is a code communicative of many complex operations of the poet's mind, not the least of which is the possibility for political engagement. From epigram to epic, the poetry of seventeenth century England is majestically topical, although staunchly resistant to exclusively topical interpretation.

But poems, it must be said, do not undertake anything poets do. Indeed, the poets who communicate by means of genres have intentions, and these intentions are historical events, just as the occasions for which they are written are historical events. Hence, my third theoretical concern is with authorship and gender. This dyad marks the point where history becomes theory and theory history. More specifically, the period saw a great increase in the number of poets writing, poets from a wider range of classes and inclusive of both genders. In short, the emergence of the status of the "professional" author in the period an eventuality occasioned by the increased commercial potential of printed poetry collections, and in some instances occasioned in distinct opposition to the vicissitudes of print culture opened the way for a richer, more various poetry. In many ways, this process was the most distinguishing feature of the age, producing the conditions in which its greatest poets flourished.

These theoretical concerns, broadly delineated, will be applied to the poets on my list, who are organized under the rubric of four thematic categories. These categories of necessity will be even broader in conception, more inclusive, which itself strikes me as a move toward better understanding the period in its own terms. This is not, however, to conform to the older conceptions of "Cavalier" and "Metaphysical," to the schools of Donne and Jonson. For such a conception of the period is not only misleading, but radically inaccurate when one considers the extent to which these poets share integral forms, features, concerns, and even addressees. In place of the familiar binarisms, I propose to categorize the poets who should fall into more than one of these categories as 1) classical, political, secular, occasional; 2) sacred; 3) love; 4) epistemic (i.e., scientific, technological, psychological, topographical, "country house"). Of course, these thematic categories will be challenged by the works themselves, particularly by the greater works, which inexorably challenge us in our attempts to quantify or qualify their theoretical concerns or thematic strains.


Fulke Greville (1554-1628)
— "Elegy on the Death of Sidney" (1586?)
— Selections from Caelica (1633)
XXXVIII ("Caelica, I overnight was finely used")
LV ("Cynthia, because your horns look diverse ways")
LV1("All my senses like beacons' flame")
LXXX ("Clear spirits, which in images set forth")
LXXXII ("You that seeke what Life is in Death")
LXXXVII ("When as man's life, the light of human lust")
XCVI ("in those years, when our sense, desire and wit")
XCVII ("Eternal Truth, almighty, infinite")
XCVIII ("Wrapp'd up, O Lord, in man's degeneration")
XCIX ("Down in the depth of mine iniquity")
C ("In night when colors all to black are cast")
CII ('"The Serpent, Sin, by showing human lust") GUNN p. 131
CIX ("Sion lies waste, and thy Jerusalem")
Aemilia Lanyer (1569-1645)
— Selections from Salve deus rex Judaeorum (1611)
"The Description of Cooke ham"
"To the Lady Arabella"
John Donne (1572 1631)
Songs and Sonnets (1663 pub.)
Divine Poems (1607-9 writ.; 1633 pub.)
The Anniversaries (I An 1611; comp. ed. 1612)

Ben Jonson (?1572 1637)
Epigrams (1616 F)
The Forest (1616 F)
The Underwood (1640 W)

Lady Mary Wroth (c. 1586-c.1652)
— Selections from Pamphilia to Amphilanthus (1613-1621 [pub. with Urania])
Sonnet 6 ("O strive nott still to heape disdaine on mee") ROB p.88
Sonnet 14 ("Am I thus conquer'd? have I lost the powers") ROB p.94
Sonnet 22 ("Like to the Indians, scorched with the sunne") ROB p.99
Sonnet 23 ("When every one to pleasing pastime hies") ROB p.99
Song 4 ("Sweetest love returne againe") ROB p.100
Robert Herrick (1591-1674)
— Selections from Hesperides (1648)
"The Argument of His Book" (H 1)
"Another [to His Book]" (H 5)
"When He Would Have His Verses Read" (H-8)
"His Request to Julia" (H-59) 5.
"To the King, Upon His Coming with His Army into the West" (H-77)
"Delight in Disorder" (H-83)
"Dean bourne, a Rude River in Devon, By Which Sometimes He Lived" (H-86)
"Corinna's Going A Maying" (H-178)
"The Lily in a Crystal" (H-193)
"To Live Merrily, and to Trust to Good Verses" (H-201)
"To the Virgins, to Make Much of Time" (H-208)
"His Poetry His Pillar" (H-211)
"Art above Nature: To Julia" (H-560)
"His Return to London" (H-713)
"The Pillar of Fame" (H-1129)
Henry King (1592-1669)
— Selections from Poems (1657)
"An Exequy to His Matchless Never to be Forgotten Friend"
"Sic Vita"
George Herbert (1593 1633)
— The Temple (1633)

Thomas Carew (?1594-1640)
— Selections from Poems (1640; 1651)
"An Elegy upon the Death of Dr. Donne, Dean of St. Paul's" (1633)
"In Answer of an Elegiacal Letter upon the death of the King of Sweden from Aurelian Townshend" (1633)
"To My Friend, G.N., From Wrest" (1640)
"To Saxham" (1640)
"A Rapture" (1640)
Edmund Waller (1606-1687)
— Selections from Poems (1645, 1664, 1668, 1686)
"Upon Ben Jonson" (1638)
"At Penshurst [1]" ("Had Sacharissa...") (1645)
"At Penshurst (2j" ("While in the park I sing...") (1645)
"Song (Go, lovely rose!)" (1645)
"On St. James's Park, As Lately Improved by His Majesty" (1661)
"Of English Verse" (1668)
"Of the Last Verses in the Book" (1686)
Sir Richard Fanshawe (1608-1666)
— From Il Pastor Fido (1648): "An Ode Upon occasion of His Majesties Proclamation in the yeare 1630. Commanding the Gentry to reside upon their Estates in the Country"

John Milton (1608-1674)
Poems (1645)
— Additional shorter poems (1673) & uncollected lyrics (1694)
Paradise Lost (1667; 74)
Paradise Regained (1671)
Samson Agonistes (1671 tog. w/ PR)

Anne Bradstreet (1612-1672)
— Selections from Several Poems, 2nd ed. (Boston, 1678)
"A Dialogue Between Old England and New: Concerning Their Present Troubles, Anno. 1642"
"The Author to Her Book"
"To My Dear and loving Husband" — From the Andover MSS. (pub. 1867): "Upon the Burning of our House July 10, 1666"

Richard Crashaw (?1612/13-1649)
— "Upon Bishop Andrewes's Picture before His Sermons" (1631) F 502
— "Wishes: To His (Supposed) Mistress" (1641)
— From Steps to the Temple (1646; enlarged 1648)
"Upon the Body of Our Blessed Lord, Naked and Bloody"
"The Weeper"
"A Hymn to the Name and Honour of the Admirable Saint Teresa" — From Carmen Deo Nostro (Paris, 1652): "A Letter from Mr Crashaw to the Countess of Denbigh, Against Irresoloution and Delay in Matters of Religion"

Sir John Denham (1615-1669)
— From Poems and Translations (1668): Cooper's Hill ("pirated" 1642; "authorized" 1655; 1668)

Abraham Cowley (1618-1667)
— Selections from The Mistress (1647)
"Written in the Juice of Lemmon" #5
"The Wish" #19
"The Thief" #21 — Selections from Miscellenies (1656)
"The Motto"
"The Grasshopper"
"Ode: Of Wit" — From Pindarique Odes (1656): "To Mr. Hobbes"
— From Verses Written on Several Occasions (1668): "To the Royal Society" (pub. 1667; collected 1668)

Richard Lovelace (1618-1656 or 1657)
— Selections from Lucasta (1649)
"Song: To Lucasta, Going beyond the Seas"
"Song: To Lucasta, Going to the Wars"
"The Grasshopper. Ode. To My Noble Friend, Mr Charles Cotton"
"Gratiana Dancing and Singing"
"To Lucasta. From Prison. An Epode"
"To Althea, from Prison: Song" — Selections from Lucasta Posthume (1659 60)
"To Lucasta" ("Like to the sentinel stars...")
"A Mock Song"
Lucy Hutchinson (1620-post 1675)
— "Verses Written By Mrs. Hutchinson In the Small Book Containing Her Own Life, and Most Probably Composed by Her During Her Husband's Retirement from Public Business to His Seat at Owthorpe" (comp. c.1660 3) FOW 587; GREER

Andrew Marvell (1621-1678)
— Selections from Miscellaneous Poems (F, 1681)
Upon Appleton House
"An Horatian Ode upon Cromwell's Return from Ireland"
"The Coronet"
"The Garden"
"To His Coy Mistress"
"The Definition of Love"
"On a Drop of Dew"
"The Mower against Gardens"
"Damon the Mower"
"The Mower to the Glowworms"
"The Mower's Song"
"On Mr. Milton's Paradise Lost"
"A Poem on the Death of His Late Highness the Lord Protector"
The Last Instructions to a Painter
Henry Vaughan (1621/2-1695)
— Selections from Silex Scintillans (Silex I, 1650)
"The World (1)"
"The Retreat"
"The Morning watch"
"The British Church"
"Vanity of Spirit" — Selections from Silex ll (1655)
"The Waterfall"
"Abel's Blood"
"The Proffer"
"The Night"
"The Book"
Margaret Cavendish, Duchess of Newcastle (1623 1673)
— Selections from Poems, and fancies (1653)
"Of Many Worlds in this World" NOR p.479
"A Dialogue betwixt Man, and Nature" NOR p.480
"Similizing the Sea to Meadowes, and Pastures, the Marriners to Shepheards, the Mast to a May pole, Fishes to Beasts" NOR p.482
"Of Stars" FOW p. 631
"A Landscape" FOW p. 633
John Dryden (1631-1700)
— "Heroic Stanzas Consecrated to ...Oliver [Cromwell]" (1659)
Astraea Redux (1660)
Annus Mirabilis (1666)
— "On Milton" (1688)

Katherine Philips (1632-1664)
— Selections from Poems (1667)
"On the 3. of September, 1651" NOR p.171
"To the Excellent Mrs Anne Owen, upon Her Receiving the Name of Lucasia, and Adoption into Our Society. 28 December 1651" FOW p.696
"Friendship's Mystery, To My Dearest Lucasid NOR p.517
"Friendship in Embleme, on the Seal. To my dearest Lucasia" N 518
"To My Excellent Lucasia, on our Friendship" NOR p.521
"Orinda to Lucasia" FOW p.698
"An Answer to another perswading a Lady to Marriage" N p.378
"Upon the graving of her Name upon a Tree in Barnelmas" N p.483
Thomas Traheme (1637-1674)
— Selections from the Dobel MS (collected 1670?; pub. 1903)
"The Salutation"
"The Preparative"
"The Rapture"


Bush, Douglas
— English Literature in the Earlier Seventeenth Century, 2nd ed. (Oxford: OUP, 1962).

Carey, John
— John Donne: Life, Mind, and Art (New York: Oxford UP, 1981).

Corns, Thomas, ed.
— The Cambridge Companion to English Poetry, Donne to Marvell (Cambridge: CUP, 1993).

Fish, Stanley E.
— Surprised By Sin: The Reader in Paradise Lost (New York: St. Martin's, 1967).
— Self Consuming Artifacts: The Experience of Seventeenth Century Literature (Berkeley & Los Angeles: U of California P, 1972).
— The Living Temple: George Herbert and Catechizing (Berkeley & Los Angeles: U of California P, 1978).

Goldberg, Jonathan
— Desiring Women Writing: English Renaissance Examples (Stanford UP, 1997).

Hammond, Gerald
— Fleeting Things: English Poets arid Poems, 1616 1660 (Cambridge: Harvard UP, 1990).

Harvey, Elizabeth D. and Katherine Eisaman Maus, eds.
— Soliciting Interpretation: Literary Theory and Seventeenth Century English Poetry (Chicago: U of Chicago P, 1990).

Kerrigan, William
— The Sacred Complex: The Psychogenesis of Paradise Lost (Cambridge: Harvard UP, 1983).

Kerrigan, William and Gordon Braden
— The Idea of the Renaissance (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins UP, 1989).

Lewalski, Barbara K.
— Writing Women in Jacobean England (Cambridge: Harvard UP, 1993).
— Protestant Poetics and the Seventeenth Century Religious Lyric (Princeton: PUP, 1979).
— Paradise Lost and the Rhetoric of Literary Forms (Princeton: PUP, 1985).

Martz, Louis L.
— The Poetry of Meditation: A Study in English Religious Literature of the Seventeenth Century, rev. ed. (New Haven: Yale UP, 1962).

McClung, W.A.
— The Country House Tradition in English Renaissance Poetry (Berkeley and Los Angeles: U of California P, 1977).

Norbrook, David
— Poetry and Politics in the English Renaissance (London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1984).
— "Preface" and "Introduction," The Penguin Book of Renaissance Verse, 1509-1659 (Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1992).

Patterson, Annabel
— Censorship and Interpretation: The Conditions of Writing and Reading in Early Modern England (Madison: U of Wisconsin P, 1984).

Post, Jonathan F. S.
— "Substance and Style: An Introduction to The Temple," George Herbert Journal 18: l &2 (1994 95): 1 28.

Riggs, David
— Ben Jonson: A Life (Cambridge: Harvard UP, 1989).

Rogers, John
— The Matter of Revolution: Science, Poetry, and Politics in the Age of Milton (Ithaca: Cornell UP, 1996).

Smith, Nigel
— Literature & Revolution in England, 1640-1660 (New Haven: Yale UP, 1994).

Tayler, Edward W.
— Donne's Idea of a Woman: Structure and Meaning in The Anniversaries (New York: Columbia UP, 1991).
— Milton's Poetry: Its Development in Time (Pittsburgh: Duquesne UP, 1979).
— "Introduction," Literary Criticism of 17th Century England, ed. E.W. Tayler (New York: Knopf, 1967), pp. 3-32.

Tuve, Rosemond
— Elizabethan and Metaphysical Imagery (Chicago: U of Chicago P, 1947).

Wall, Wendy
— The Imprint of Gender: Authorship and Publication in the English Renaissance (Ithaca: Cornell UP, 1993).

One of the scholarly rituals that anyone interested in understanding the breadth of Renaissance poetry must perform is to read the historical overviews Lewis 1954 and Bush 1945 (the third and fifth volumes of the Oxford History of English Literature) on 16th- and 17th-century verse. You will probably find grounds for disagreement with their surveys, but you also will have to admire their skill in covering an immense number of works in different genres, while presenting a literary transition that takes readers from the late Middle Ages to the Restoration. Although, by turns, quaint, quirky, and weathered, Lewis was a voracious reader who still provides the best comprehensive study of the development of English Renaissance poetry in the 16th century: and he does this in alternating chapters that parallel philosophical and stylistic changes in verse and prose. He also successfully grounds the period’s poetic forms in the work of the late Middle Ages, providing an excellent context for assessing their native antecedents. Nevertheless, his division of the century between an earlier “Drab” and a later “Golden” style, as Winters 1967 has shown, is too pejorative and simplistic to account for the patent merits of the so-called plain style in the work of poets such as George Gascoigne. In line with Lewis’s estimation, however, Waller 1993 is an especially impressive treatment of the literary genius of Spenser and Sidney. Bush’s command of the field is equally impressive. He recognizes, from the start, the need not to insist too firmly on a difference between “cavalier” and “metaphysical” poets, since these conceptual modes and their resulting styles shared a more fluid interrelation in 17th-century verse. And he does not neglect the towering figure of Milton or the age’s heroic verse. Of the many more recent guides, Waller 1993 and Cheney 2011 provide excellent introductions to the earlier Renaissance, while Parfitt 1995, with a few questionable evaluations, renders a similarly comprehensive account of later developments.

  • Bush, Douglas. English Literature in the Earlier Seventeenth Century, 1600–1660. Oxford History of English Literature. 2d ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1945.

    E-mail Citation »

    Bush provides an expert analysis of how Renaissance poetry was shaped by the concerns of its age, as he situates poetic form within the literary, social, political, and religious tendencies of Stuart culture. The period’s major poets are each considered in a separate chapter.

  • Cheney, Patrick. Reading Sixteenth-Century Poetry. Malden, MA: Wiley-Blackwell, 2011.

    DOI: 10.1002/9781444396560E-mail Citation »

    Cheney divides his study among Henrician, Edwardian, and Marian poetry from 1500 to 1588 and Elizabethan poetry from 1588 to 1603. Focusing on the pleasures and uses of poetry, he organizes his book around a series of historical changes that can be seen in the key categories of voice, perception, world, form, and career. A helpful bibliography is appended.

  • Lewis, C. S. English Literature in the Sixteenth Century, Excluding Drama. Oxford History of English Literature. Oxford: Clarendon, 1954.

    E-mail Citation »

    This is an excellent starting point for students who want to secure a firmer knowledge of 16th-century English verse in its various permutations. Lewis is nevertheless at his best when considering the “Golden” period realized by the masterpieces of Sidney and Spenser.

  • Parfitt, George. English Poetry of the Seventeenth Century. Longman Literature in English. 2d ed. London: Longman, 1995.

    E-mail Citation »

    Parfitt’s book complements Waller 1993 in the same series. It analyzes lyric, the poetry of place, poems of occasion, satire, and epic. It has a chronology, a general bibliography, and bibliographies of individual writers. Together Waller and Parfitt furnish a set of intelligent and wide-ranging introductions that emphasize the political and social conditions that shaped the writing of poetry.

  • Waller, Gary. English Poetry of the Sixteenth Century. Longman Literature in English. 2d ed. London: Longman, 1993.

    E-mail Citation »

    Waller’s informative account of the period extends from Dunbar and Wyatt to Shakespeare and Donne, and it is organized into chapters devoted to contemporary engagements with the period. Chapter 8, “Gendering the Muse: Women’s Poetry, Gay Voices,” and Chapter 9, “Conclusion—Reopening the Canon,” typify the author’s interest in producing a more inclusive evaluation. The volume features a chronology, general bibliographies, and notes on individual authors.

  • Winters, Yvor. Forms of Discovery: Critical and Historical Essays on the Forms of the Short Poem in English. Chicago: A. Swallow, 1967.

    E-mail Citation »

    “The 16th Century Lyric in England” was originally written in 1939 and then revised for this book. In his assault on the English Renaissance canon, Winters responds to Lewis 1954 by dividing 16th-century lyric between the “plain” and “sugared” styles to suggest the superiority of such unappreciated authors as Barnabe Googe, Nicholas Grimald, Jasper Heywood, Thomas Nashe, and George Turberville, who were capable of direct, forceful, and moving verse. The “sugared” style is too sweet for Winters’s taste.

  • 0 thoughts on “17th Century Poetry Essay Format

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *